“Primates have an advanced system of communication that
includes; vocalization, hand gestures, and body language. Humans have evolved
even further, we have achieved something that primates have not; spoken
language” (http://science.howstuffworks.com). I had never realized how
difficult it is to communicate without speaking verbally or even to communicate
without gestures and emotion but only spoken language, but it is difficult. It
is hard to believe that there was once a time when humans did not use spoken
language. While doing the Language Assignment Experiment, I found that both the
absence of spoken language and the absence of all body language and gestures hinder
communication.
The
first part of the Language assignment was to spend 15 minutes taking part in a
conversation without using spoken language. I found that this was difficult,
but it wasn’t impossible. I was still able to communicate with body language
and gestures such as nodding my head or making a certain face depending on if I
agreed or disagreed with what they were saying. I did this assignment with both
my parents and I filled them in on the assignment before-hand. If I could re-do
the assignment, I would leave my participants in the dark about the guidelines
to the assignment because I felt since my parents knew what I was doing; they
didn’t react as naturally as they would have in a normal situation. I did
notice that since I was not communicating verbally back to them, that they
somewhat drifted away from talking to me and instead continued the conversation
between themselves. It would be interesting to see how this conversation would
have gone between two people from different cultures. As advanced as we have
become with spoken language, I feel that the culture that is demonstrating the
spoken language would have the upper hand. This is because we rely so heavily
on spoken language, that one might not know how to react in a situation where
the other culture does not use it. An example of two different cultures that
might be on different communication levels is someone who is deaf and relies on
American Sign language and gestures to communicate and someone who is able to
hear and speak and uses verbal language freely. Some people might feel
uncomfortable knowing that they can’t communicate in the way that they are used
to, but I believe that body language, expression, gestures, and emotion are a
huge part of communication. In fact, without all that it would be difficult to communicate
on a daily basis.
The
second part of the Language assignment was to spend 15 minutes taking part in a
conversation only using spoken language. To communicate without using physical
embellishments, hand signals, vocal intonation, or body movement. This part of
the assignment was difficult; in fact, I thought it was more difficult than the
first part of the assignment. I was not able to complete the full 15 minutes;
at least I couldn’t finish it while taking it seriously. It is difficult to
express how you feel about something without using the different devises such
as gestures or expression. This part was not easy for my parents to participate
in either. They didn’t seem to take me as seriously when I spoke everything in
a monotone expressionless robot tone. In fact, we ended the experiment early
because we were laughing at how silly I sounded. The “use of signs” in language
is a large majority of the communication process, in fact, without “non-speech
language techniques”, I believe that communication would be extremely
difficult. There are a lot of different
people in the world who have trouble reading other people’s body language whether
it is someone who is autistic, naive, or just simply does not catch on easily
to others gestures; there are plenty of people who just don’t understand. I
believe that it is important to know how to speak with expression and body
language but I am sure there are some situations when the use of body language
is not necessary. One might believe that the use of body language and gestures
is not necessary when they are communicating with someone who cannot physically
see; someone who is blind. I don’t think that there is a benefit to this, just
the fact that it may not be as necessary in this situation as it is in others.
Humans have come a long way, and I believe communication such as spoken verbal
language, and body language is one of our best achievements!
Works
Cited
"HowStuffWorks
"Science"." HowStuffWorks "Science". N.p., n.d.
Web. 19 Mar. 2013. <http://science.howstuffworks.com>.
Riggio, Ph.D.,
Ronald E. . "Reading Body Language: It’s Not Easy, But You Can Improve
." Psychology Today. N.p., n.d. Web. 18 Mar. 2013.
<http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/cutting-edge-leadership/201106/reading-body-language-it-s-not-easy-you-can-improve>.
I find it interesting that you found the first part of the assignment easier than the first. Although you could not use gestures, I feel as though the conversation went smoother then the first. In the first part of the experiment my partner got frustrated and ultimately did not take it seriously. My second experiment, although I use gestures in every day life, I was able to have a steady conversation. Good job!
ReplyDeleteVery good description and analysis in Part A. I appreciate your reflection and discussion throughout. Well done.
ReplyDeleteWell done as well in Part B. Great insight and discussion on the value of body language in communication.
Actually, even though people who are blind can't read body language, they can "read" intonation in your voice, so body language of a sort is still important to those who can't see. What about a situation where you might misinterpret body language, such as when you are visiting a different culture? Might it be better to ignore body language in that setting until you learn what the body language means?
Other than this last point, great post.
I had not thought about the fact that one might not know if they were miss-interpreting body language or ignore body language while in a cultural setting that they are not used to, but it is definitely possible. If fact, it is likely that a miss-interpretation or miss-communication would occur in that situation.
DeleteHi Krystal,
ReplyDeleteLooks like we had the same outcome in our experiment that Part B was more difficult than Part A. I think that when it comes to explaining a complex idea, communicating with words will be the most efficient form. But when you want to express how you feel or what item of clothing you want to wear or what you want to eat, symbolic language will do just fine.
I enjoyed your reflection of the experimental outcomes and your blog overall.